Monday, June 02, 2014

Over my dead body


It looks like the Church of England has entered the fray regarding the new high speed rail line between London and the North of England (HS2). Apparently the Arch Bishops Council has announced that it's opposed to the line being built for a number of reasons, primarily that graves along the route will be desecrated. It's an interesting angle, you'd think taking a position that places the interests of dead people over living people would seem fairly negative but clearly death is a particular concern of the complainants. The logic (not that logic has a big role to play in this) seems to be that since people have been buried in "consecrated" ground then they would be upset if their remains were disturbed and moved elsewhere. Somewhere in that sentence the fact that these people no longer exist seems to have been lost; even if the Christian view of what happens after death is true (pretty unlikely) then the remains are still just "empty vessels", I'd be fascinated to hear how theologians would explain previous owners of these bodies could be upset or disadvantaged if what's left of the lifeless remnants of their bodies are moved or even destroyed (by cremation for example). Now I can understand living relatives getting upset if undue irreverence were shown during the moving process but it must be impossible to lift a single sod of earth on this crowed little island without disturbing the residual molecules of some long since deceased Neanderthal, Pagan, Roman, Viking, Saxon or other immigrant worker, perhaps they can give the decomposed corpses jobs collecting tickets, might breath a bit of life into the whole thing.

5 comments:

Archdruid Eileen said...

To be fair, the C of E have only asked that the remains of the dead are treated respect, not opposed the whole scheme.
There's a good tradition of moving the remains from graveyards reverently. When the St Pancras line was put in through St Pancras churchyard, the relocation of remains and the arrangement of the headstones into a weird circle around an ash tree was arranged by Thomas Hardy during his architect phase. The tree and headstones are all still there.

Archdruid Eileen said...

I do wish they would oppose it, mind you. Stupid bloody idea. We could make the rest of the network work for that.

Steve Borthwick said...

AE, yes I can see both sides of this, it's a lot of money and it could certainly be used to spruce up the network but I can't help thinking that sometimes you need a flagship project to spur future action, much like they did in France. We invented flippin railways in this country it's depressing to be beaten at our own game by "the old enemy", then again, it's the World Cup soon :)

A Heron's View said...

Which "old enemy" are you referring to for there are a lot of old enemies out there ?

Steve Borthwick said...

HV, you're not wrong there, I like to hope that the list diminishes over time though. (France BTW)