Tuesday, September 06, 2011

Pray kid, or else...

I was listening to a random program on Radio Berkshire this morning about a recent survey of parents regarding compulsory prayer at school, many people probably don't realise that having a daily act of (Christian) worship in school is actually the law in England but the meat of the program was focused on the fact that most schools don't do it. Various arguments were aired for and against, and whether or not this law should be enforced. There's a reasonable summary of the story on the BBC news site.


Parents apparently have the right to withdraw their children if they wish and sixth formers can choose for themselves, however my view is that withdrawal of young children from a majority activity and the obvious stigma that would be associated with this is probably more harmful than just going along with it and simply teaching the child to think for themselves, evaluate the evidence and come to their own conclusions.

What I found encouraging about the program was that the pro-worship side had utterly dismal arguments, easily on a par with Piers Morgan, some of them are repeated in the on-line article, for example The Bishop of Oxford seems to think that forcing people to pray together makes a statement about cohesion, what nonsense, if you look up the word "divisiveness" in the dictionary it says "see religion". The solution seems obvious to me religion (or any similar cultural hobby) should not be a mandatory part of any state school timetable unless it's being taught comparatively to everyone, the law should be changed.

2 comments:

Lisa said...

I didn't know about this, Steve, until the hub sent me the BBC story about it, knowing I would find it interesting. Glad my kid is not at a state school, even if most them ignore this foolishness.

They certainly should change the law, but you know how people are uncomfortable with dealing with this kind of thing. Easier to ignore it.

Steve Borthwick said...

Lisa, most private ones are more adherent in my experience, my kids have "chapel" every day! - totally agree about most people not wanting to cause a "fuss", especially the English!